Are We the Belugas Now? How Barnum’s 1861 Circus Became Silicon Valley’s Business Model
A Raging, Unfiltered, Uncomfortable Op-Ed on Captivity, Power, and the Monsters We’ve Become
One afternoon in 1861, an 11-year-old Boston girl recorded something grotesque in her diary—something so disturbing you would assume it came from a dystopian sci-fi novel, not American history. She watched a beluga whale, terrified and thrashing, driven like a horse by a girl in a boat. A collar around its neck. Rains [sic] attached. Men chasing it down just to strap it in.
This wasn’t a fever dream.
This wasn’t fiction.
This was entertainment.
Phineas T. Barnum—yes, the “Greatest Showman” the movie whitewashed into a quirky genius—was busy capturing live beluga whales from the St. Lawrence Seaway, shipping them to Boston and New York like disposable props. Most whales died within days. Barnum didn’t care. Why would he? To him, whales were “plentiful,” renewable fuel for spectacle. If one died, just grab another from the river. Load it onto a train. On to the next.
Barnum wasn’t a visionary entrepreneur.
He was the original tech bro:
hyper-profitable, morally bankrupt, and riding the suffering of others straight to the bank.
And this is where the story should make you very, very uncomfortable.
Because as monstrous as Barnum’s actions were, he set a blueprint—one we still live in today.
A blueprint where sentient beings are exploited, drained, displayed, and discarded for the amusement and enrichment of the powerful.
A blueprint that Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg, and Elon Musk have perfected.
Belugas in Concrete Pools. Humans in Algorithmic Tanks. Same Circus, New Ringmasters.
Let’s be brutally honest:
Beluga whales are intelligent, social, culture-bearing beings with complex relationships, dialects, migration knowledge, and emotional depth—parents, siblings, aunties, friends. In the wild they travel hundreds of kilometers a day. They play. They communicate. They teach their young how to survive.
And what do we give them in captivity?
A concrete pool.
A sterile environment.
A predictable routine so mind-numbing it breaks their minds.
Orcas smashing their heads against walls. Dolphins chewing concrete.
This isn’t enrichment.
This is incarceration.
Yet somehow, we think we’re different.
Are we?
Because every day we wake up inside our own man-made tanks—glowing rectangles, algorithmically curated echo chambers, workplaces optimized for surveillance, consumer habits molded like soft clay. Our behavior tracked. Our emotions manipulated. Our voices harvested for data. Our attention monetized.
We’re not wearing collars.
But the reins are there.
And the people holding them are billionaires.
Barnum wanted whales for profit.
Bezos wants you for profit.
Zuckerberg wants your memories, relationships, identity, reality.
Musk wants your future, preferably encoded in a neural chip or shipped to Mars.
Are we the belugas?
Or worse—have we become the trainers, cheering on the next trick as long as the show goes on?
Captivity Isn’t Just a Tank. It’s an Economy.
Captive whales didn’t end up in tanks because of bad luck. They ended up there because:
• Humans love dominance disguised as education.
• Corporations love profit disguised as conservation.
• Governments love inaction disguised as regulation.
• And the masses love entertainment disguised as compassion.
The same formula powers Big Tech.
SeaWorld says captivity “educates.”
Facebook says data extraction “connects people.”
Amazon says worker exploitation “delivers convenience.”
Tesla says cobalt mining “saves the world.”
Behind each slogan?
A tank.
A cage.
A pipeline of suffering.
Meanwhile, Wild Animals Are Still Being Jailed for the Pleasure of… Whom Exactly?
Let’s not dress this up:
Captive cetaceans are not held for science.
Not for education.
Not for conservation.
They are held for entertainment.
For people who want to watch animals who have suffered their entire lives perform tricks that imitate joy.
So let’s ask the forbidden question:
What kind of person takes pleasure in a whale doing tricks in a concrete bathtub?
Sadists?
Monsters?
Or simply people so numbed, so disconnected, so indoctrinated by consumer culture that they can’t recognize cruelty unless it hits them on the head?
If the audience were forced to watch an orca being torn from its mother, dragged by ropes, trapped in a net, strapped into a sling, and flown across continents…
Would they still clap?
Probably not.
Which is why the industry hides it.
Just like tech companies hide how your data is farmed.
Just like fossil fuel companies hide the bodies behind the barrels.
Just like billionaires hide how they built their fortunes on the broken backs of the many.
The Science Is Clear. The Morality Is Clear. Only Greed Remains Uncertain.
A new PeerJ paper—written by six animal-welfare scientists—states unequivocally:
• No concrete pool on Earth is large enough to meet a cetacean’s physical or mental needs.
• Captivity causes chronic stress, boredom, immune dysfunction, and early death.
• Orcas and other cetaceans exhibit self-harm behaviors seen in tortured, traumatized beings.
Let me repeat:
Self-harm behaviors.
If this were happening to humans in institutions, the world would riot.
But for whales?
We call it a “family attraction.”
Canada Finally Banned It. Others Will Follow. But It’s Not Enough.
In 2019, Canada said enough.
Captured cetaceans: banned.
Breeding: banned.
Public display: banned.
Marineland Canada, the infamous death camp for whales, is finally collapsing under the weight of its own cruelty.
But here’s the twist that exposes the entire global hypocrisy:
Marineland tried to sell surviving whales to a theme park in China—one so notorious for animal abuse that even the Canadian government refused export permits.
A country that once hosted human zoos won’t allow whales to be shipped to China’s torture-tanks.
That’s how bad it is.
The Solution Exists. We Just Haven’t Grown the Spine to Demand It.
Elephants have sanctuaries.
Big cats have sanctuaries.
Great apes have sanctuaries.
Even abused farm animals now have sanctuaries.
Cetaceans? Still waiting.
Why?
Because marine parks don’t want to give up the profits.
Because governments don’t want the backlash.
Because the public loves comfort more than truth.
But the truth is simple:
If we don’t retire captive whales to sanctuaries, we are repeating Barnum’s sins with better branding.
**So Let Me Ask This Again, Loudly:
Are We the Belugas Now?**
We cheer for tech billionaires as they build rockets and buy islands.
We applaud their fortune as if it’s a personal victory.
We surrender our data, our attention, our privacy, our agency—willing captives in invisible pools.
And like belugas circling endlessly in concrete tanks, we’re told the same thing captured whales hear:
This is for your own good.
This is the best we can do for you.
This is progress.
This is the future.
But the truth is ugly:
Anyone who profits from captivity—of whales or people—is not a visionary.
They are a jailer.
A keeper of living prisoners.
A modern Barnum.
And maybe, just maybe, the real reason whales still suffer in tanks is because we still accept our own.
yours truly,
Adaptation-Guide
No comments:
Post a Comment